Jump to content
Romeo Void

WA to ban puppy farms!

Recommended Posts

SummerStar

Edited by SummerStar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oriental lily

they have been banned in vic for a while now . I don’t think it’s made a zero amount of of difference . It just gets hidden better . Which in a way makes it worse because a council does not even get to do a sporadic chance of an inspection .

 

but google designer dog breeders in vic and you get heaps of oodly doodley monstrosities for sale everywhere .

 

many would deffinetly fit a description of a puppy farm but because they are not licensed as one they fly under the radar .

 

i am not convinced legislation does anything for animal welfare . Education about sourcing family pets from ethical registered breeders is the only thing that will work .

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Romeo Void

I don't know how the Vic version works but this sounds like they're really trying to put the thumb screws on it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oriental lily

Actually just read the article more carefully . It said it will stop ‘illegal puppy farms ‘ so those with a license and registered with a council that are microchipped as coming from that farm are still allowed . Legal puppy farm are still very horrible for a dog to live in and the standards are still very low. .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
#notallcats

Actually just read the article more carefully . It said it will stop ‘illegal puppy farms ‘ so those with a license and registered with a council that are microchipped as coming from that farm are still allowed . Legal puppy farm are still very horrible for a dog to live in and the standards are still very low. .

 

Yes you'll have to be a registered breeder, and the pup/dog should be able to be traced throughout its life. Pet stores won't be able to sell puppies, only re-home pup/dogs from shelters. It's a start, not perfect, and probably about 20 years too late. I don't know why you think it's only 'designer' dog breeders that are horrible, I'm sure there are plenty of purebred breeders that are too. 'Oddles are here to stay, and we are better off trying to register/examine their practices than ban. Ideally all breeding would be banned while dogs linger in shelters but selfishness prevails.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SummerStar

Edited by SummerStar
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oriental lily

The confusion comes on what people consider a ‘registered breeder ‘

 

you can be registered with the council .

you can registered with your states dog society VICdogs ect .

you can be registered with a MBA , which welcomes x breeds like the oodles .

 

Or you can register with breed development groups like the group trying to get the Aussie bulldog a recognised breed ..

 

all these can claim to have registered puppies . But many of these groups don’t have strict ethical standards that they enforce . Talk the talk but don’t walk the walk .

 

ultimately it makes very little difference on what breeders claim to be registered with . No good breeder will sell pups to a pet shop . So automatically sourcing a pup there even before it became illegal should be a no go .

 

the best way to get a ethically bred dog is to do your own research . Straight away a good search will show why designer breeds are a no go .

 

then you need to find a good breeder of purebred dogs with a excellent reputation . There is heaps of resources online on how to find one .

 

i think all the legislation in the world can not replace your own personal research on finding a good breeder .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ozquoll

Okay, this is a genuine question so please don't flame me - what's so bad about cross breeds? The best dog I ever met was an unholy mix of god-knows-what. I can see that oodles have been a bloody disaster, but isn't that more because people have bred them for a certain look rather than focussing on temperament and trainability?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
But seriously

My vet who I asked advise from in regards to what sort of dog did not have a problem with some cross-breeds. We got a cavoodle. On his advice. Are you saying that vets are ill-informed?

 

I agreed with you about pet shops - and my vet said no dogs from pet shops as they are always likely to be anxious and there are other issues. He also said no dogs from interstate - you dont get to meet their parents

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SummerStar

Edited by SummerStar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SummerStar
On 10/02/2020 at 4:55 PM, Ozquoll said:

 

 

 

Edited by SummerStar
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
annodam

My vet who I asked advise from in regards to what sort of dog did not have a problem with some cross-breeds. We got a cavoodle cross-bred mutt. On his advice. Are you saying that vets are ill-informed?

 

I agreed with you about pet shops - and my vet said no dogs from pet shops as they are always likely to be anxious and there are other issues. He also said no dogs from interstate - you dont get to meet their parents

 

 

 

Fixed it for you!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
But seriously

Are you a vet?

 

There are no guarantees with any pet. We have a pure bred cat and a rescue cat and now a dog. They are all lovely in their different ways

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SummerStar

Edited by SummerStar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
But seriously

I am certain our vet is not a breeder.

 

And it makes them an expert at least on pets and their various issues.

 

I take professional advice from professionals. Same as I would a medical doctor.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SummerStar

Edited by SummerStar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oriental lily

Purposefully bred x breeds are unethical because .

 

the breeders lie and say they don’t inherit the bad bits of both breeds . You only need a basic understanding of genetics to understand that’s a croc .

 

they have no standard they follow . So a pup can look like a mix of their parents , the father , the mother or some weird throw back in its line ( that’s why multi generations of a x breed is deffinetly not better )

 

most are bred for profit . Not for the betterment of the breed .

good ethical purebred breeders import lines from all over the world to widen gene pools . This costs a fortune . Not profit to be made .

they say many a hypoallergenic . Lie because non one can predict the adult coat of a mixed breed .

 

they often have structural issues due to parents looking massively different from one another . I recently do a Bernese mounatain dog crossed with a mini poodle . If they inherit the light bone frame the poodle but the muscle mass of the Berber well can you imagine ?

 

no one is saying all purebred dogs are ethically bred either . I think French bulldogs should never be bred due to health issues . Most brachy breeds are a disgrace .

 

but you if you do your research you can find ethically bred dogs .

 

like the little Havanese puppy I am getting in 6 weeks!

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
*Spikey*

I am certain our vet is not a breeder.

 

And it makes them an expert at least on pets and their various issues.

 

I take professional advice from professionals. Same as I would a medical doctor.

 

Actually, it doesn't make them a specialist in breeding. It makes them a generalist in treating diseases of companion animals, and livestock, and occasionally natives and zoo animals.

 

a vet can administer a genetic test, but they aren't geneticists.

 

Would I trust a vet to tell me about the disease of the dog in front of me? Absolutely. Do I expect them to be informed about the breeding programs and genetic screening of over 300 breeds of dog alone? Nope.

 

And if a vet tells you that a Cavoodle is a breed, doesn't warn you about where they are bred and the circumstance likely to be involved in the purchase you make, plus explaining the genetic lottery when it comes to shedding, and inherited diseases from both breeds, then they're not a particularly informed vet. In fact, I'd go as far as saying, they're not a particularly good vet. A quick observation of the muscularskeletosystem of any cross bred dog tells you there's will most likely be issues. So why a vet would recommend a dog that is going to be expensive to buy, and even more expensive to keep alive and comfortable is beyond me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
#notallcats

You seem to think that because a vet said it must be so.... Instead of researching the why yourself.

 

That sounds like an anti-vaxer doing their own "research" rather than accepting expert opinion.

 

Anyone talking about "ethical' breeders while dogs sit in shelters are not in a position to judge anyone else's choices. There are just as many rubbish breeders of pure breed as mutts. Perhaps more.

 

The boat has long sailed on 'oodles'. People need to accept it and work with it, to ensure the dogs are cared for, instead of ridiculing owners. I don't believe anyone should be breeding but even I can accept it's going to happen, so let's make sure proper laws are in place. (and perhaps registering the breeds so they have a governing body).

Edited by #notallcats
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
franklymum

Yes you'll have to be a registered breeder, and the pup/dog should be able to be traced throughout its life. Pet stores won't be able to sell puppies, only re-home pup/dogs from shelters. It's a start, not perfect, and probably about 20 years too late. I don't know why you think it's only 'designer' dog breeders that are horrible, I'm sure there are plenty of purebred breeders that are too. 'Oddles are here to stay, and we are better off trying to register/examine their practices than ban. Ideally all breeding would be banned while dogs linger in shelters but selfishness prevails.

 

Run - leave this thread now. Time is too precious!

 

My vet who I asked advise from in regards to what sort of dog did not have a problem with some cross-breeds. We got a cavoodle. On his advice. Are you saying that vets are ill-informed?

 

I agreed with you about pet shops - and my vet said no dogs from pet shops as they are always likely to be anxious and there are other issues. He also said no dogs from interstate - you dont get to meet their parents

 

Another poor soul. Trust me - this thread only ever goes one way. I love EB normally but my unasked for advice is to stay away from the pure bred dog threads - any dog that isn't a pure bred is a mutt, anyone who has a mutt is evil and there is no grey area, there is only black and white. Pure bred dog breeders are incredibly vicious about protecting their income streams. Not that they do it for the money of course - it's only out of the goodness of their dog loving hearts and a virtuous desire to maintain pure blood lines.

 

For those who may wish to flame me, feel free but I won't be around to read it sorry, I've got to wash my hair. Not flouncing, just wanted to make a quick public service announcement for any other poor unsuspecting EB members who may not have had the pleasure of meeting this particular demographic.

Edited by franklymum
  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SummerStar

Edited by SummerStar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
#notallcats

Not that they do it for the money of course - it's only out of the goodness of their dog loving hearts and a virtuous desire to maintain pure blood lines.

 

 

I did chuckle at that bit too.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SummerStar
On 10/02/2020 at 7:59 PM, franklymum said:

 

 

Edited by SummerStar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
#notallcats

 

 

I am surprised there are so many supporters of dodgy breeders who even defend that choice to support such an industry. I hope they do bring in a ban on breeding if not registered with a recognised breed body. It's the only way to stop it because too many people clearly don't care what they buy or its history.

 

I'm surprised you and others are so stubborn over 'oodles'. No we are not supporters of BYB, and no I'm not a supporter of "ethical" breeders either. But I am a realist. Register the breeds, give them a governing body... because 'oodles' are not going away, and while people are charging $2k++, at least make them accountable.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...