Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Caitlin Happymeal

ABAS 3 or vinelands cost approx?

Recommended Posts

Caitlin Happymeal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lees75

I would get a Vineland done, rather than an ABAS, as NDIS prefer it for access purposes.

 

You will probably find it is cheaper to go to an OT than a psych, although if you need a diagnostic assessment to get an ASD Level, you will need to go to a psych. But they will need to do more than just a Vineland, I would imagine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
José

Have you already applied for NDIS and been knocked back or are you just anticipating what they might need.?

If there are multiple commodities an ABAS or vineland alone will be unlikely to be enough to assign a level re: ASD.

Do you already have a psych or paed involved that cpuld assign a level if required?

An ABAS or vineland should show functional impairments, which NDIS should like, but on its own it couldnt say whether the impairment is due to ASD or the other diagnoses. And the ABAS doesn't really address the restricted repetitive interests part of ASD. So while it may be useful i wouldnt think on its own its enough for a person who doesn't know your child to give a level.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jmjsa

Our daughters psych did her abas and I am pretty sure that she just charged 1 hour so $200 for the report. Our daughter is level 1 and I believe that the abas really helped and we got what I considered a good ndis package.

 

Another option could be a uni. We had a heap of testing done, Wisconsin, wiat and a few others and all up it cost us $250.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Volsk

If it’s just to apply for the NDIS you shouldn’t need it.

We were just approved for DS15. We gave them his original ASD diagnosis paperwork. He was diagnosed at 4 so it’s old! We also gave them a letter from school, a letter from his psych, a speech assessment (that showed no delays) and a letter from the GP. That was it. He doesn’t see a speechie or OT so he saw the speechie at school for the assessment. School can also organise for the Vineland to be done through student support services

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Froyo

I don't know how old your child is, but as a primary school teacher I regularly complete Vinelands. It's part of the job.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Caitlin Happymeal

Thanks for the help folks :)

 

She's 10, has level 1 ASD/ADHD/a variety of anxiety diagnoses and a few medical issues. Her psych who we've had for ages wrote a stunning and compelling letter on her needs and addressed the appropriate NDIS domains, her paed gave supporting evidence, and she was still knocked back.

 

Meanwhile, her twin sister who is level 2 but actually has less functional impairments because she's not crippled by anxiety 100% of the time is accessing NDIS with no questions asked. That level 1 vs level 2 thing has really stuffed us up.

 

So this ABAS or vinelands (psych we are seeing on tue can do both) is our last ditch attempt to get her access. I will also be writing a carers impact statement.

 

I'm sort of over it but also don't want to give up the fight, which is exhausting.

 

Froyo and smileykylie, I had no idea teachers/schools could do it... hmmmm.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Crombek

Teachers can't interpret or report on the results, but they are often asked to fill in a questionnaire as well as the caregiver. It's so we can look at how situational or global the child's impairments and strengths are and is really useful information to have for goal setting and intervention planning.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
José

A vineland and ABAS is a checklist that is completed by a person who knows the target person.

So, a teacher who knows a child well can complete a checklist, just as the parent can complete the checklist.

Neither a parent or teacher can purchase the checklist from the supplier directly, or score the checklist or interpret and report on the checklist.

A school psychologist could do it, however, there are waitlists and this is unlikely to be a priority for them. And school psychs are unlikely to be overly familiar with how to write for NDIS.

Why can't the usual psych do this? seems extremely strange to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lees75

In the situation you have described, I think the Vineland is preferable, although you could always ask the psych to send you the link to the Carers form for the ABAS, then you can do it at home, so it won’t cost extra money, and then they can include the results in their report as extra evidence of functional impact.

 

My only other thought, if you have already been denied because of a lack of functional evidence, NDIA tend to prefer an OT functional report, rather than a psych. The report needs to outline the functional difficulties in the 6 domain areas of mobility, self-care, self management (which is age related chores, life skills, such as catching the bus, etc), learning, communication and social interaction. And it needs to include wording that is along the lines of “substantially reduced functional capacity in the domains of.........” as that is the eligibility requirement wording. With the evidence to back it up, i.e. Vineland or ABAS, as well as clinical and functional observations.

 

ETA It is important to remember that not a lot of NDIA staff are trained in disability, so they don’t have the skills to read a report and interpret what it means. It needs to be pointed out to them in their specific lingo.

Edited by Lees75
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Caitlin Happymeal

Yeah the regular psych CAN do it, as in, has the training, but the clinic she practices out of don't own the tools themselves. Which is super annoying. But she is also a fabulous clinician so we are sticking with her long term.

 

The psych we are seeing for this upcoming assessment - well, when I booked, I thought it was going to be with an OT. It's being done through our other daughter's therapy hub, who are very much up on NDIS speak and how to access it. Current psych is in an area that only just had NDIS rollout (We moved to a rolled out area recently) so they aren't quite au fait with it all just yet. They are getting there but it's such a convoluted system to navigate.

 

Gosh it's so frustrating.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Caitlin Happymeal

Sounds like it's similar to the Connors (Or is it conners?) That we did for her ADHD diagnosis in that we filled it out, teacher filled one out and psych interpreted it. That was a few years ago though and a different psych.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
José

Sounds like it's similar to the Connors (Or is it conners?) That we did for her ADHD diagnosis in that we filled it out, teacher filled one out and psych interpreted it. That was a few years ago though and a different psych.

 

I suppose you could say its similar to the Conners. but its assessing completely different things.

You read a bunch of statements and then choose the appropriate answer e.g. can do the task independently, needs help to do the task etc etc.

 

I still think it's highly unusual for a psych working with children not to have an ABAS OR a Vineland. They must never ever do assessments!

Sounds like the people you are seeing know all about NDIS which is good!

 

FWIW a psych who had seen my son long term charged $500 for an ABAS report. The practice didn't charge for the form and because of our situation we didn't require any face to face appointments. If we had seen him at all (E.g. to discuss reason for assessment, to receive and discuss report) we would have been charged for those sessions as well which is something like $220 per session. That would have pushed it close to the $1000 mark.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Caitlin Happymeal

I think they dont do the assessments because they are a NFP and they are running on the smell of an oily rag. I think their model is going to have to change as more people in that area access NDIS.

 

Anyway, it's all good. I'll see what I can find out tomorrow over the phone.

 

I really,truly appreciate everyone's input - this whole situation is just so frustrating. Two people with the same condition, and a number in the diagnosis that makes all the difference. It's so much more complicated than "levels".

 

Anyway, I'll keep trying. She needs the support so badly - we want to give her so much more than we can.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MsLaurie

Is the sticking point that NDIS is viewing the main issue as anxiety (& therefore “medical”), rather than ASD (& “disability”)?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
José

Is the sticking point that NDIS is viewing the main issue as anxiety (& therefore “medical”), rather than ASD (& “disability”)?

 

It seems the main problem is the primary disability is ASD level 1. The OPs child with an ASD level 2 diagnosis was approved.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lees75

ASD Levels 2 and 3 are both NDIS List A conditions, which means acceptance is likely with no further evidence required.

ASD Level 1 is a List B condition, so further evidence of functional impairment is required.

Edited by Lees75
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Caitlin Happymeal

Exactly what Lees75 said. My understanding is that all ASD was originally to be covered under NDIS but they tightened the access requirements quite early on, limiting it to level 2-3 that qualify without much, if any, supporting evidence. They really dont get what the word spectrum means.

 

Well, ABAS done, sensory profile done, psychologist will tally up scores and write a report. Seemed to suggest that DD might possibly fit a level 2 diagnosis, and if so, best approach is to approach paed with the evidence and see if a change of level is possible/appropriate.

 

And going back to my original question, cost was under $500. Which was good.

 

Thanks all for the assistance :) It has helped. Now I will just wait and see if anything comes of it.

 

Hate how many times I have to talk about all the things my daughters can't do, just to get them support.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jmjsa

Our daughter was given a level 1 diagnosis by psychiatrist but abas report (which was really, really, really low) stated that her needs were level 2. She was accepted for ndis and got almost identical funding to her twin who received a level 2 diagnosis from psychiatrist

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...