Magratte, November 27, 2019 in Miscellaneous
My son was 7 when he asked, he is a very logical kid with a scientific brain and it just didn’t make sense to him anymore. He loved being part of the adult world the next Christmas after that and thought he was so grown up knowing something that his sister didn’t.
My daughter is 7 now and she has started making some comments that make me think she’s questioning things. If she comes straight out and asks I will answer her truthfully.
My first DS worked it out at about 4 So we have never made a big deal of it or tried too hard to make them believe. I know DS9 was told by his cousin about 2 years ago, but DS5 is completely convinced despite being surrounded by non-believers and even tries to convert them! He's a Santa-evangelist
He is 12 now and going along with still in a way i think but maybe 9/10 when starting to ask questions
DS asked around 6.5. I held him off with “what do you think?” for a few months and then, when he said he really wanted to know, I told him it was me. He then had hysterics about how lovely I was to buy him all those things.
Next day he had blocked the whole thing out, or pretended he had, or who knows how his mind works.
Now at 8 he talks about Santa all the time, but says stuff like “when Santa gets me a Nintendo Switch it will be mine and you can’t say turn it off”.
My youngest doubted it from about 3 and would say outright Santa isn’t real. He still plays along though 5 years later.
His older sibling says she still believes.
They humour me as they know I love Christmas. I have a friend who told her children “if you don’t believe you won’t receive” and suggested I do the same. I told her my kids know I got a Santa stocking right up until the Christmas before my mum died so they know that saying isn’t true.
If you believe you receive in my house
Not sure. My eldest is almost 11 and I have no idea. Youngest is 6. They all seem to go along with it. I'm sure they could just google the answer if they really wanted to
DD was still absolutely convinced at 12 (Dec birthday), so we told her.
i don’t think DD believes, she is almost 4 and never really got the Santa thing. We probably did something wrong! Her childcare friends might convert her... I don’t mind either way, but a bit of Christmas magic creates wonderful memories!
I was 7/8 when I asked mum and was told but I was the second child and older sibling didn't believe so as a parent myself it's easier when everyone just knows so there's no hiding etc. Mum was probably relieved I asked.
My kids have all been told just after Christmas the year they started high school because my husband reckoned he believed and got into a fight over it when he went to high school because his parents never told him.
We just have one left who believes and we have a few years yet before high school. She always knew dressed up people were fake from the age of 3, was always switched on differently to the others so I really thought she'd have worked it out by now, she's also not one to play along so I'm pretty sure she doesn't know and isn't saying.
Have to say I am a bit over it though. Three who are well past it as am I. It's wonderful when everyone believes but hard when some do, some don't. Will be good when I don't have to watch what I say and sneak around Christmas night.
I’ve had to confess to miss 10 because it was making her cross. The others just accepted it was their choice. Now they all choose to believe because it’s more fun that way.
I was 7/8 when I asked mum and was told but I was the second child and older sibling didn't believe so as a parent myself it's easier when everyone just knows so there's no hiding etc. Mum was probably relieved I asked. My kids have all been told just after Christmas the year they started high school because my husband reckoned he believed and got into a fight over it when he went to high school because his parents never told him. We just have one left who believes and we have a few years yet before high school. She always knew dressed up people were fake from the age of 3, was always switched on differently to the others so I really thought she'd have worked it out by now, she's also not one to play along so I'm pretty sure she doesn't know and isn't saying. Have to say I am a bit over it though. Three who are well past it as am I. It's wonderful when everyone believes but hard when some do, some don't. Will be good when I don't have to watch what I say and sneak around Christmas night.
I don't hold anything against my mum at all but she was not good at hiding the evidence.
I knew for a while but thought I was onto a good thing so never let on for quite a few years
DS1 was around 4 or 5 I think. DS2 definitely knew by 4. DS3 is 8 and only starting to question it now. To be honest I'm hoping he works it out this year, I'd rather not have to keep up the pretence.
I had it figured out by 5. My oldest figured it out last year at 10 and the youngest child at 9 is very very very insistent that Santa is real. He believes in magic and fairies as well. I love that he sees magic in everything while at the same time loves science and hard facts. Then again he’s the same child who insists that art is science and since is art.
Like a PP I kinda wish he’d figure out Santa isn’t really because I find it a total pain to pretend.
Don't think either child really believed but still plays along in their teenage years. The magic of Giftmas doesn't have to be solely tied to a belief in Santa.
I was all over Santa by 5 as is DD, also 5. She clued in via the Easter bunny. The bunny is not real, does that mean Santa is not real too? She’s happy enough to play along though and hasn’t been spreading her discovery as far as I’m aware.
We never went to a huge effort to create and support the myth so the outcome isn’t that surprising.
Emmdasher we don’t either, but it’s like the myth that won’t die! I swear my youngest believes less when younger then he does now. Santa doesn’t even bring the big gifts, just small stuff because I refuse to let a make believe character get all the credit on hit gifts. Though maybe it had something to do with the teapot when he was 6 that he really really wanted and then forgot he told me about that turned up Christmas Day to squeals of joy and a sincere belief in magic since.
DD is 9.5 and seems to still believe.
i kinda wish I'd never started the whole santa thing because I really don't like lying to her.
She had a teacher in 1st grade tell the class Santa wasn't real and was a bit upset about it but I told her that everyone believes different things and that's ok, but it's not ok to tell someone their belief is wrong. Some of the kids were REALLY upset apparently.
Thanks for nothing random relief teacher!
I know I was told by mum at 10 that it was the last year I'd get a santa gift because mum knew I knew the truth lol.
I must have worked it out or been told by other kids.
I found a pro and con list a few weeks ago that my son 13 made. Number 1 for Santa being real.
My mother buys me everything I meant or need until she is broke and cries about being poor. Santa brings me stuff my mum could never afford.
Apparently Santa is still real
My son is eleven and claims to believe but I personally think that is BS. He has asked for a very expensive gift he is definitely not getting and I think he is testing me.
Not sure how I feel about Christmas Day.
We get our magic by decorating the front of the house with lights and entering the town lights competition. We have a lovely carols night where winners and honourable mentions are announced. I describe our design aesthetic as “elf vomited in the front yard”.
I still remember the day I worked it out. I was about 7 and I was at a friends house, she showed me a card santa had given her and I recognised her mother's handwriting.
I definitely knew that I was onto a good thing and kept quiet to my parents for several years. I think eventually I would open the santa presents and then thank Mum and Dad for them anyway. (Even though I totally knew it was all Mum and my Dad would have had no idea what was even in any of the presents).
DD has only just turned 6 and as far as I know has no reason not to believe just yet.
I am not game to ask them, as my reality may be very different to their reality. I like to live in the bubble of thinking that they did not know until I told them.
My brother and sister threatened me with physical violence if I let on that I knew. Being older than me, they were still getting Santa Presents and knew that it would stop when I fessed up. I think that it was several Christmases after I knew that my parents realised that I knew.
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Started Sunday at 02:06 AM
Started 6 hours ago
Started 5 hours ago
Started July 1
Started July 17
Started July 26
Started July 26
Just Another Cat
Started 11 hours ago