Welcome to the Lo-Fi, text only version of Essential Baby's forums.
The
Essential Baby forums cover all areas of
parenting and stages development for
babies,
toddlers and
kids as well as
parenting lifestyle areas including
Family Travel,
Finances,
Nutrition & Wellbeing,
Recipes and more!
If you'd like to post and interact with EB's
parenting forums read more articles about
conception,
pregnancy,
babies,
toddlers,
kids or more please visit
Essential Baby for the full site experience.
mummame
14/04/2011, 04:39 PM
I am very careful about not 'stealing' a friends baby name, or immediate family etc. I know it would annoy me if I had my heartset on a name and then have someone use is jus t before me. What do you think the ettiquette is on children already born though? LIke a toddler or older child's name.
I have a distant relative of a family member, like a cousins wife's daughter, I have met once in my life! I feel silly even asking but do you think I could use the name of this persons child, who is 2, even though I did not get the idea off them obviously as I dont talk to them. I just like this name, its also the name of my sisters friends sisters' daughter complicated!!
It feels fine to me, but when I mentioned to my sister she said 'nope i would not use it' in the case of the distant family members relation. She is over the top with this sort of thing though, like does not want to offend anyone even though there is no reason for offense!! This just seems silly to me, apart from Facebook where i may see posts etc, I have no contact with this person so it seems dumb to forgo this name for this reason. I can understand if it was a family member i have a lot of contact with though.
What would you do? Its dumb hey, like not even an issue
3_for_me
14/04/2011, 04:41 PM
Distant family member no worries
Bel Rowley
14/04/2011, 04:41 PM
Of course you can use it.
Freckles
14/04/2011, 04:43 PM
If it's a name you really love and it's someone that you rarely see I would go for it. I know some people are very funny about it but to me it's like the ultimate compliment. My DS is Patrick and I have a friend who I see quite a lot, who called her DS (born 2 years after mine) Patrick. Afterwards she asked me if I minded and I said no, not at all. It does make life a bit crazy when they are around but with different middle names (starting with different letters) it's not been a problem.
I think people have different ideas about what is acceptable and what isn't. In the situation you are describing I would go for it.

HTH.
blackcat20
14/04/2011, 04:44 PM
If its someone you never see, Id go for it. If it was your bestie/close family, that would be a different story.
MamaP
14/04/2011, 04:45 PM
Unless it is super unusual I'd use it.
I'm in the position where I love the name jemima but my cousin has used it for her daughter and the family are all pretty close so it's a no go! Yours sounds much more distant though so I say go for it!!
mummame
14/04/2011, 04:46 PM
I literally cannot think of any possibly occasion where i will see this person again in my life, maybe a funeral, which would be the only one and thats a maybe as well, very distant not blood related to me at all. Obviously with facebook this person will know and I dont want them thinking oh you stole the name off me, silly! It seems with no contact in our everyday lives it would have to be petty of them to have an issue.
sarah77r
14/04/2011, 04:49 PM
I don't think it should be an issue in that case. I think the only time I wouldn't use a name is if my sibling used it for their child and possibly if a very close friend used it too.
me+him+her
14/04/2011, 04:53 PM
i dont think its an issue - oi say go for it??
whats the name op? if you dont mind sharing??
Buggylicious
14/04/2011, 05:43 PM
Unless it was a rather unique name I'd go for it.
riwymk
14/04/2011, 07:04 PM
I personally wouldn't. It would feel weird to me to name my child the same name as a family member (without it being in memory of someone etc) But that's just me.
As for using a name that someone has mentioned to you. Unless that person is a close friend or family member then it's up for grabs. But only if it's a name you actually really love & not just to spite someone (because I've known people to do this)
the4rugrats
14/04/2011, 07:05 PM
I would use it. My #4 child has the same name as one of my 1st cousins. We don't see each other and very unlikely that we ever will again. We chose the name because of a lovely lady we met, and even though I knew I had a cousin with the same name it didn't worry me. Besides that it was the only name DH and I could agree on! LOL
KayDan0707
14/04/2011, 07:15 PM
QUOTE (Freckles @ 14/04/2011, 04:43 PM)

If it's a name you really love and it's someone that you rarely see I would go for it. I know some people are very funny about it but to me it's like the ultimate compliment. My DS is Patrick and I have a friend who I see quite a lot, who called her DS (born 2 years after mine) Patrick. Afterwards she asked me if I minded and I said no, not at all. It does make life a bit crazy when they are around but with different middle names (starting with different letters) it's not been a problem.
I think people have different ideas about what is acceptable and what isn't. In the situation you are describing I would go for it.

HTH. Funny...I've just posted a reply in a similar thread saying the same thing. My DS2 is also Patrick and my best friend's DS (also my Godson) is Patrick too. She was delighted and her DS was so proud that we wanted to choose his name. There is a 7 year difference between them but at no stage has it every caused a problem.
In your particular case, I don't even think I would've given it a second thought.
baddmammajamma
14/04/2011, 07:19 PM
If it were a very unusual/distinctive name, then I wouldn't use it.
(For instance, I don't think anyone in your extended family or network of friends, Buggy, should use "Denver" because it is such a distinctive name and would (in my opinion) seem like copy catting...)
But otherwise, fair game!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.