Welcome to the Lo-Fi, text only version of Essential Baby's forums.

The Essential Baby forums cover all areas of parenting and stages development for babies, toddlers and kids as well as parenting lifestyle areas including Family Travel, Finances, Nutrition & Wellbeing, Recipes and more! If you'd like to post and interact with EB's parenting forums read more articles about conception, pregnancy, babies, toddlers, kids or more please visit Essential Baby for the full site experience.
Home - Become a Member - Login - Forums
Full Version: my 3 yo doesn't seem to understand the concept of questions
HOME | CONCEPTION | PREGNANCY | BIRTH | BABY | TODDLER | KIDS | LIFESTYLE | TOOLS

Essential Baby > Toddler & Kids > 3-5 Years
dueMarch
every time i ask him a question he just repeats it right back to me.. like "do you want some water?" he says "want some water?" (i usually take this as "yes").
"did you hit your sister?" he answers "you hit sister?" (not sure what this means sometimes when his 6 month old sister cries he says he has hit her but he really hasn't???)

i've seen other 3 year olds even 2 year olds with much less vocabulary than my son being able to give a good "yes" / "no" answer to most questions so i am wondering if this is a form of language development issue.

he seems to grasp the idea of some questions that involve the word "what" or "which" for eg. "what did you do today?"
he usually says the same thing however like "i played with my toys" (no variation even if today he has gone swimming or done something else)

otherwise he has a good vocabulary range, can make sentences and sings songs,etc.

i don't know if this is related but he doesn't pronounce the "k" / "s" / "f" sounds properly. he says "pish" (fish),
"tik" (six) and "tar" (car).

i've had his hearing checked and this is fine.
please has anyone come across another child that does this? any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Carmen02
QUOTE
don't know if this is related but he doesn't pronounce the "k" / "s" / "f" sounds properly. he says "pish" (fish),
"tik" (six) and "tar" (car).

That is quite normal.
I would encourage him to say yes or no, if he repeats what you said just say to him yes or no, even if you know what he means get him to say yes or no, encourage him to say it and don't take repeating as an answer. my 3yr old DS is like that but he has moderate speech delay
mamfa
If you think its not normal or you want some input, book him in to get a speech assesment. Not sure if its the same Au wide but its free in Vic for Speech(public). My son had an assesment and they suggested hearing loss and to get him tested. they were right and i was very thankfull for that. although it dosn't sound like that is the problem.

there are many condition that involves speech and the earlier you both learns to change/manage it the better. but hopfuly its just a leaning stage for him.

good luck
imagine22
i think the pronounciation is fine but the question thing is funny original.gif

maybe try some really obvious role playing with your partner ie Do you want a drink of water" "yes please" and you give him a glass of water.

and try delaying giving your son something until he answers with a yes

i dont know though just suggestions.

my DD1 has been answering with yes and no since 18 months and gave nodd yes answers much earlier than that i think.
K1
My DS (almost 3) has a question problem too, but instead he asks questions instead of stating wants/needs. Eg, he will say "do I want a glass of milk?" rather than "I want a glass of milk".

He also has the same pronounciation issues as your DS.

However he has been speaking in complete sentences for more than a year, has an outstanding vocab and demonstrates an understanding of abstract concepts, so I'm not worried.

I think they're just experimenting with patterns of speech and language rules. English is a very complicated language; even for native speakers it takes a fair while to get the hang of it (some people haven't even got it right as adults).

I wouldn't worry if I were you.
Jackie1966
I think that you should have him assessed. This type of repeating questions back can sometimes be a sign of autism. I certainly don't say that to worry you but I think you should see a specialist just to be sure everything is okay.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Essential Baby is the place to find parenting information and parenting support relating to conception, pregnancy, birth, babies, toddlers, kids, maternity, family budgeting, family travel, nutrition and wellbeing, family entertainment, tips for the family home, child-friendly recipes and parenting. Try our pregnancy due date calculator to determine your due date, or our ovulation calculator to predict ovulation and your fertile period. Our pregnancy week by week guide shows your baby's stages of development. Access our very active mum's discussion groups in the Essential Baby forums to talk to mums about conception, pregnancy, birth, babies, toddlers, kids and parenting lifestyle. Essential Baby also offers a baby names database of more than 22,000 baby names, popular baby names, boys' names, girls' names and baby names advice in our baby names forum. For the latest baby clothes, maternity clothes, maternity accessories, toddler products, kids toys and kids clothing, breastfeeding and other parenting resources, check out Essential Baby.