Jump to content

Monash Med Centre vs. Jessie McPherson
Public vs Private - pregnancy care

  • Please log in to reply
7 replies to this topic

#1 anon360

Posted 18 April 2012 - 08:04 PM

Hi All

Just a quickie.  If you were deemed 'high risk' due to high blood pressure and Type II DM and a few other issues, do you feel it is better to go with Monash Med Centre as a public patient or through private OB at Jessie McPherson.

Just wondering if anyone has been deemed 'high risk' and went public at Monash Med Centre and how did they find it, appointment times etc, waiting rooms, same Drs/nurses each time or different etc.

Their website says what their protocol is but was wondering if it really is that way or not.  Don't know whether to pay big management fee to private OB if care will be similar.  Also how will the private OB care be different.

TIA. biggrin.gif

#2 anon360

Posted 19 April 2012 - 11:44 AM


#3 Missmarymack

Posted 19 April 2012 - 11:54 AM

If I was deemed high risk I'd personally prefer to start in th public system - the likelihood of a high risk pregnancy being transferred to public from private is pretty high, so I'd rather start there anyway.

#4 belsy

Posted 19 April 2012 - 11:59 AM

Hi OP,

I didn't go through either but take DS for regular blood tests which is next to the maternity services unit.  From my experience it always very full and you can also have a fair wait for the blood and other tests you need.

I have to say you can have a long wait at an OBs office as well.

I had a friend who had 2 babies at Jessie Mac, it was really good and great care, had own room and shower.  She had two VBACs there.  I understand if there are serious medical conditions with the baby they will transfer them to the Monash part anyway.

I have had one private and one public - you generally see the one OB when private, with public OB (I had to see in later part of pregnancy) this can vary depending who is on the clinic duty.  The longest I had to wait at private OB was just over an hour, public was over 2 hours.

I prefered the private, mostly because I had my own room and shower facilities and DH could stay overnight.  I was aiming for a VBAC second time round and went public but ended up with another c-section.  I had a trainee doing the staples, which were too deep and ended up with infection.  With the private OB, he did a great job on incision and staples and he came everyday to my room to check up on me.

It's also important to remember that generally a private hospital will not admit you if you have baby before 36 weeks.  I am not sure if this is the same with Jessie Mac since it is co-located though.

Good luck with your pregnancy, I don't know if I helped much.

#5 MothershipConnection

Posted 19 April 2012 - 12:07 PM

For me personally I wouldn't ever go back to MMC to give birth as a high risk patient.  I'd go Jesse Mac.  I had a horrible experience at MMC.  I had no "voice".  The nurses/midwives barely spoke to me, wouldn't discuss my own care with me, and seemed hell bent on getting my baby out as quickly as possible even if it meant increasing the risks to me and my baby.  

I should clarify that I was deemed high risk because I had gestational diabetes and my local community hospital does not have an anaesthetist at the hospital 24 hours a day.  But he is "on call" and he told me that if I needed an emergency C section in the night I could end up in real trouble and so he recommended I go to a tertiary hospital, so I did.

I was induced for no medical reason despite protesting.  My labour was progressing at a normal rate in comparison to my previous 3 labours.  Short of leaving the hospital and going somewhere else in the middle of labour I was given no alternative.  I was made to wear a monitor even prior to being induced and because I kept moving around (trying to get comfortable as well as re-positioning to open up my pelvis) and so the monitor kept losing my son's HB, but everytime the strap was re-positioned his HB was perfect.  The nurses also called a doctor in to deliver my son by forceps with no discussion with me and for no medical reason.  His heartbeat was fine, but I was upset because they kept wanting to do thing "to me" instead of treating me as a person and talking to me.

The first I knew that the doctor was there to deliver with forceps was when I saw him unwrap the kit.  The midwife looked at me and told the doctor was here to give me a little help.  I was shocked.  Really shocked and not happy.  I thought he was there just to see how far I had progressed because of the induction.

Anyway, I didn't need the forceps...I pushed my son out quite quickly after I saw those things..tore pretty badly too, but I didn't want forceps anywhere near me unless it was absolutely necessary.

I really felt like a faceless person with no voice and no way out.  I felt trapped and unsafe.  It was not a nice feeling.

My waters had actually broken not long before midnight late in the evening and I went to the hospital soon after as it is a 40 minute drive for us so didn't want to leave it until it was too late.  I really believe because I was dealing with night duty nurses/midwives my care was compromised.  I just don't think they could be bothered with me.  

On the other hand, I've worked as an agency nurse at both MMC and JM and feel the nurses at JM take more care with their patients in general.

Someone else will probably come in now with an opposite story (L) but there is mine for all it is worth.  HTH.

Edited by MothershipConnection, 19 April 2012 - 12:12 PM.

#6 MuminMtEliza

Posted 19 April 2012 - 12:45 PM

Hi OP,

I would definitely go private with Jessie Mac if I was deemed hi risk. I've had both my children at Jessie, once I was transferred there after my waters broke at 34 weeks (the hospital I was booked into wont accept you before 36 weeks), and with the second, I decided to be prepared at book in at Jessie from the start. My DS who was born at 34 weeks was admitted to Monash NICU but was treated as a private patient. Only difference this made was that our DS had the same paed looking after him all the time - not just whichever doctor was on duty. The hospital requested we did this so they could recoup some of the expenses from our PHI. My DD, was born at 35 weeks and went straight to Jessie's SCN.

The main reason I would go private is continuity of care. I was also admitted twice to Jessie before my DD was born - once at 33 weeks for PE and again at 34 weeks for pneumonia. Both times I was in a hospital bed as soon as I arrived - not sure whether there would have been a longer wait at MMC.

My cousin gave birth at a large tertiary hospital as she was diabetic and needed extra care, however when her DS was born, he was put in SCNto monitor his insulin levels, and she was in a room with 5 other women and babies. Its hard enough not having your baby in the room with you, but then to have 5 other babies in the room, all crying and feeding at different times night and day, is pretty hard to take.

Only downside at Jessie is their food - it is disgusting but it is the same food as MMC. However, most women won't choose Jessie for their food or rooms etc, more so that they have a SCN, access to NICU and are experts in hi risk pregnancies. Good luck.

#7 Guest_bottle~rocket_*

Posted 20 April 2012 - 06:05 PM

QUOTE (handsfull @ 18/04/2012, 08:04 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Hi All

Just a quickie.  If you were deemed 'high risk' due to high blood pressure and Type II DM and a few other issues, do you feel it is better to go with Monash Med Centre as a public patient or through private OB at Jessie McPherson.

Just wondering if anyone has been deemed 'high risk' and went public at Monash Med Centre and how did they find it, appointment times etc, waiting rooms, same Drs/nurses each time or different etc.

Their website says what their protocol is but was wondering if it really is that way or not.  Don't know whether to pay big management fee to private OB if care will be similar.  Also how will the private OB care be different.

TIA. biggrin.gif

I think the standard of care for your pregnancy complications would be the same if you went public or private, it's just that you would have more continuity of care if you have a private obstetrician.

I haven't been to MMC as a public patient but did go through private OB and was a patient at Jessie McPherson.  My OB had a lot of patients, and I waited over an hour sometimes for appointments and they usually lasted 5-10 minutes.

The Birth Suites at MMC are used by both private and public patients, so I'd assume it is the same midwives providing labour and delivery care for both types of patients.  

The difference is that during your postnatal stay in Jessie Mac you are more likely to have a private room than in the public section, although even there most women stay in a shared room for at least the first night after birth before being moved to a private room.  

I can't comment on the protocols on the MMC website, but if they don't follow protocol then at least you can refer to this if you are negotiating certain things with them.  
If you have a private OB then the type of care you receive is more dependent on your OBs preferences.

Edited by bottle~rocket, 20 April 2012 - 06:19 PM.

#8 Freycha

Posted 20 April 2012 - 11:41 PM

I recently gave birth at MMC and 2 weeks later my sis also had her bub a Jessie Mac.  These are the main differences i found:- yes you get a private room in Jessie mac and your DP will have the option of staying overnight (I was actually glad my DH went home to get a proper sleep so he could be nice a rested to help me during the day....and he snores! Ha!)- food is better at JMac but all hospital food is a bit yuk so much of a muchness really. My fam brought me in food (there's fridges in MMC so you can store your own food!) - you get more free samples of baby products at Jmac...- JMac has carpet...
Birthing suits are used by both public and private so same midwives for all patients. My experience with the midwives was excellent. I was in there for 30+ hours and they were just amazing and even had a few visit me on the ward. I was induced, had epidural and bub was assisted delivery but i never once felt I wasn't fully informed or in control of my decisions. Terrible that others didn't get the same experience. I also knew my bub had some minor birth defects and the hospital was fully prepared and had all the relevant specialists at the delivery which was comforting.  
YES you have to share a room at MMC but you form a bit of a bond with the other ladies in your room and it's nice when you go into the nursery to feed and have people to chat to.
The public ward nurses were lovely and very helpful and offer exactly the same care as the JMac nurses so I don't think the aftercare should be a factor for you.
I do agree a private OB will be able to offer you the continuity of care that you just can't get from public leading up to the delivery. It's whether the $ is a factor for you. We did find it a minor bother having to explain every visit to a different person about DS defect but in the bigger scheme of things it wasn't a huge deal.

1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users


Mum's desperate plea as whooping cough alert issued

A desperate mother has shared a heart-breaking video of her baby struggling to cope with a coughing fit caused by pertussis.

After three years, Ranjini is free at last

Ranjini, the Sri Lankan mother of three who has spent more than three years in detention after being deemed a national security threat by ASIO, has been freed.

Pregnant woman 'safe and sound' thanks to Bataclan concert hall hero

A pregnant woman who clung for life from a second-storey windowsill during the Paris terror attacks is reportedly "safe and sound".

Why are due dates important?

From the moment you discover you are pregnant you look forward to your baby's arrival.


Welcome Christmas with your family with the Essential Baby Christmas section with lots of gift guides, activities and tips for a happy holiday.

The contest that takes advantage of desperate couples

who would use the pain of infertility as an advertising tool? Who would take the personal tragedies of infertile couples to promote their own business?

Win ABC Shop prize pack for Christmas

What a boon it would be to have your toddler's Christmas gifts covered this year. We have two awesome ABC Shop prize packs to give away to two lucky winners.

Hero dad lost his life protecting hundreds of others

He was an innocent man caught in the middle of a murderous attack on his city. But instead of running the other way, Adel Termos made a heroic decision that saved the lives of many others but cost him his own.

Text service aims to fill the void for new fathers

A new text service for fathers aims to guide men through the life changing experience of having a child.

How to grow your own groceries

Follow these 31 tips to save money and enjoy time in the garden in the kitchen.

5 great things about having a baby

Having a baby is exhausting, hard work. It's also one of the greatest joys of your life.

Sick baby could die without scarce special formula, mum says

Lizzie Cann is down to her last three tins of a special formula in short supply.

Women sue over birth control pills

More than 100 women who became pregnant after taking birth control pills have filed suit in the US.

'Their footprints are never too small to leave an imprint on this world'

When she took the pregnancy test and two lines showed up, we were both ecstatic. We couldn't wait to meet our baby.

Squeaky shoes foil adorable toddler

We're probably all familiar with the pouty bottom lip and tightly crossed arms of a tot mid-strop.

Best bands to get families dancing

I'm not talking music made especially for kids here. I'm talking music from my childhood and it's the kind to really get down to (or not).

What are pregnant women Googling?

Pregnancy is a huge change for any woman, so it's natural we'll have questions - and turn to Google to ask them.

'I want him to forgive me'

As the mother of a baby born in detention, this asylum seeker feels guilt for bringing a new life into an uncertain world of incarceration.

The unethical claims helping drive demand for formula in China

Chinese parents are being led to believe formula will enhance their child's brain development, sparking a huge demand and impacting Australian stock.

Coffee could help you live longer

New US research found people who report drinking three to five cups of coffee a day are less likely to die prematurely from heart disease, suicide, diabetes or Parkinson's disease.


What's hot on EB

Win one of two ABC Shop prize packs in time for Christmas

What a boon it would be to have your toddler's Christmas gifts covered this year. We have two awesome ABC Shop prize packs to give away to two lucky winners.

Beautiful 'now and then' images of premature babies

They are stunning photos that the parents of these beautiful no doubt feared they may never see.

Physios warn pregnant women not to crunch like Michelle Bridges

Experts are urging pregnant women not to do exactly as Michelle Bridges does when exercising, or they risk developing rectus abdominus diastasis.

Penny-pinching supermarket shoppers switching in droves

Half of Australia thinks it can get cheaper groceries by switching supermarkets, and about one in four of us have already switched.

Baby breastfed by wrong mother after hospital mix up

A newborn baby has been breastfed by a stranger after a NSW hospital bungled the identities of two newborns, devastating one mother and potentially exposing the newborn to health risks.

Nurses invent skin to skin c-section drape

The determination of three US nurses to provide immediate skin to skin contact to mothers delivering their babies by caesarean section has led to the invention of a unique surgical drape.

Baby's first photo shoot features a special guest

You can always be sure of a few things not entirely going to plan during a newborn shoot – little accidents are almost par for the course – but this shoot was memorable for a whole other reason.

We are not the family you think we are, I promise

Kids have a way of presenting a completely inaccurate impression of you, as parents, and as a family.

The hidden harm of foetal alcohol syndrome disorder

Experts believe many children diagnosed with ADHD might actually have FASD and that the number of people suffering from the condition across the country could be as high as 500,000.

Anaesthetist facing charges after ignoring woman's pain during caesarean

An anaesthetist could be punished after telling a woman enduring an "excruciating" painful C-section that she was not actually in pain.

When your baby starts life in NICU

Our daughters are finally home after spending nearly four weeks in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) at Wellington hospital.

How to save for a deposit while renting

As hard as it sounds, it is possible to save money when you rent, and certain things can be done to build a deposit faster.

Medications pregnant women should take, avoid, and think about

There are actually very few medications that must be absolutely avoided during pregnancy.

Paid parental leave uncertainty a growing concern

Eight months out from the due date of the government's PPL cut, some expectant parents are facing an uncertain time.

7 commandments of using the internet as a parent

What you need is careful, objective and repeatable science. Not anecdotes or old wives' tales, but data.

A rethink on screen ban for kids under two

With new guidelines being developed, the discouragement of use below two years of age is being revised.

10 things I want my wife to know

It's on those crazy days that I must remember to stop and let her know some things she needs to hear.

Better education about SIDS needed as deaths plateau

The number of sudden and unexpected deaths in infancy has decreased in NSW for the past 15 years but the most recent report into child deaths reveals the decline has plateaued.



Can't decide?

Check out the Essential Baby Names section for some inspiration

Essential Baby and Essential Kids is the place to find parenting information and parenting support relating to conception, pregnancy, birth, babies, toddlers, kids, maternity, family budgeting, family travel, nutrition and wellbeing, family entertainment, kids entertainment, tips for the family home, child-friendly recipes and parenting. Try our pregnancy due date calculator to determine your due date, or our ovulation calculator to predict ovulation and your fertile period. Our pregnancy week by week guide shows your baby's stages of development. Access our very active mum's discussion groups in the Essential Baby forums or the Essential Kids forums to talk to mums about conception, pregnancy, birth, babies, toddlers, kids and parenting lifestyle. Essential Baby also offers a baby names database of more than 22,000 baby names, popular baby names, boys' names, girls' names and baby names advice in our baby names forum. Essential Kids features a range of free printable worksheets for kids from preschool years through to primary school years. For the latest baby clothes, maternity clothes, maternity accessories, toddler products, kids toys and kids clothing, breastfeeding and other parenting resources, check out Essential Baby and Essential Kids.