Jump to content
Violin or piano lessons for nearly 7 year old
14 replies to this topic
Posted 27 January 2013 - 11:01 AM
Has anyone had a child start violin lessons or learn how to play the violin? Or piano?
DD1 will turn 7 in April.
We are looking at getting her into music & currently deciding between violin or piano.
I would love to hear your experiences.
DH has a piano from his childhood/teenage years that he had when learning the piano at his parents place, so if we decide on piano, we will organise for the piano to be moved to our house.
But would love to hear some experiences on you or your kids learning at this age.
Posted 27 January 2013 - 11:10 AM
I have a young relative who starting learning piano at 8 (so a little older). They weren't sure what to get her into but decided on the piano as it is easier to learn than a lot of other instruments. The violin, in particular, is very difficult to learn.
Posted 27 January 2013 - 11:17 AM
DD2 began learning the piano at 6. Mum always says that 8 is the ideal age but agreed to teach DD at 6yo. She says it was the right time for her to learn. She now believes that as long as the child can read, then they can learn music. It's been a very good thing for DD2 she's now been learning for 5 years and is working on preparation for her second exam.
Posted 27 January 2013 - 11:24 AM
A lot of schools start violin in Grade 3.
DS started piano on his 7th birthday and then violin 6 mths later at school. He's finding the piano easier (we have two in the house) but I also like the fact he is in a string group at school. I suspect he will drop the violin for a wind instrument in the next few years as he's currently teaching himself the recorder.
DD1 started piano at almost 6, after a lot of begging. I initially thought she was too young, but she is thriving. She is also learning at school and her piano teacher would not take her on as a student until she first talked to DD1's classroom and music teacher. She is easily the youngest student learning the piano at her (very highly musically regarded) school.
I would have no hesitation in starting the piano first, especially if you have a good one in your house.
Posted 27 January 2013 - 11:25 AM
DS started playing cello at nearly 7. He had no problems learning to read the music and he loves it.
The advantage with choosing violin is that if you child wants to become involved in an orchestra, then its easy (spoken by someone who played piano for 10 years - good enough to be good, but not good enough to be involved in any group musical activity )
Posted 27 January 2013 - 11:27 AM
I learnt piano as a child and violin as an adult. I would go piano to start with.
The violin is technically very difficult to learn. Starting with piano, she will learn the base theory of music and learn how to read it. If she shows a flair for music or an interest in violin, she can always pick up the violin as a second instrument.
Posted 27 January 2013 - 11:53 AM
Also mum always says that the piano gives the best basis in music. A lot of musicians can play the piano in addition to their instrument. Piano learning will never be wasted even if your child changes to another instrument later.
That said DD1 learned a woodwind and can play simple piano pieces without any lessons I think because as she can read music she can apply if to the keyboard. That indicated to me it's either easy or intuitive.
Posted 27 January 2013 - 12:03 PM
I think it's always good to start with the piano. It is a great basis for all ongoing music.
I learnt both piano and violin as a child. These days I sing and play neither.
DS started piano last year (at 6 1/2) and is going really well. He will have to pick up recorder at school this year as all year 2's at his school learn recorder. He wants to learn a brass instrument so hw needs to wait until at least year 3 (our opinion) for that.
Posted 27 January 2013 - 12:11 PM
My kids play suzuki violin- they love it most of the time. My dd1 started it in yr 3 my dd2 started in Kindy. If you want your child to be able to play in an orchestra or group then they need to do violin. I think they can learn piano when they are a bit older.
The Suzuki method proves that you can start violin at any age be it 3 or 33 and progress at your own pace!
Posted 27 January 2013 - 04:49 PM
I did piano and that age and took up violin at 12yrs. I progressed very quickly in violin from my piano background.
My 7yo is starting piano this year.
Advantage for piano then violin later is that you don't get years if bad violin playing .
Posted 27 January 2013 - 04:54 PM
My 5 year old has just started learning the piano, he is doing very well so far. He is also learning muscianship etc. I envisage he will pick up another instrument in a couple of years
Posted 27 January 2013 - 05:02 PM
I'd go piano as well.
We had a lot of trouble finding someone to take DS1 on before 8, but we got his school music teacher to do 1 term as a trial (he plays guitar though) and she agreed to take him on.
Posted 27 January 2013 - 05:04 PM
I also think the piano is the better option for a child who is starting music. I started teaching DD piano at age 5 and she is going well (she's now almost 7). There is an initial hurdle when they are still working out how to read the notes and so being able to read is an important part of that.
DD is now past that frustrating stage and loves playing (practising) but it was always important to me to make it fun. I had horrid teachers when I was a child and there was no fun in it at all and the books for beginners were really ordinary. There are some fantastic books for little fingers now with fun songs and duets so you can play together. DD had a great time playing Jingle Bells (and other carols) for everyone at Christmas time.
Posted 27 January 2013 - 07:29 PM
Thank you everyone for your replies.
All your input has help us enormously in making a decision. We spoke about it over dinner tonight & have decided to start with piano. DD is super keen & can't wait.
And if in the future she still wants to try the violin, she can.
I never did music or an instrument growing up so I have no idea.
Thanks again everyone.
Posted 28 January 2013 - 05:16 PM
My DD will be 7 next month. She has been taking private piano lessons since mid last year. It has been a wonderful outlet for her. She enjoys it too. Having a patient and competent teacher certainly helps.
Our piano teacher is actually our school music/band teacher and she does private lessons in her home for those that seek them.
Best of luck!
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users
The Duke of Cambridge has spoken of how he wishes he could ask his late mother for advice, disclosing his sadness that his own young family will never meet her.
Motherhood "isn't an exclusive club", says blogger Gylisa Jayne.
Having had three babies in three very different ways, I feel reasonably qualified to make this statement.
One couple has found a new way to make gender reveals even more over the top.
Mothers make hundreds of choices every day on behalf of their babies.
One of the weirdest things about your little kids getting older, I find, is when they start to be able to hold full conversations with you.
We all know about varicose veins, but did you know you can get them on your lady parts?
Toddler + Makeup kit = disaster.
We're in this together mamas! I salute you! Sometimes we just need to take a deep breath and realise this parenting gig is a tough one.
A new study is demonstrating that babies can do more than we think they can.
Some mums are left physically and emotionally depleted, with nothing left to give, long after giving birth.
Somewhere in the middle of my second trimester, my body changed seemingly overnight from maybe-pregnant to obvious, undeniable baby-on-board. At the same moment, my bump moved from its cushy bubble of is-she-or-isn't-she polite discretion to a free-for-all open season of body commentary.
It was a long journey to parenthood and now they are an instant family of eight.
How one dad is nailing the parenting thing.
Now you can have your baby or toddler's name printed on their Bonds Zippys.
Let's be real. All of those pictures on social media showing perfectly coiffed and smiling children are cute, but their connection to real life with kids is tenuous at best.
Top 5 Articles
From our network
Money might be funny in a rich man's world (or so ABBA told us), but for the rest of us it's a major consideration – particularly before having a baby.
Maternity leave is a special time for you, your partner and your new little bundle. The last thing you want is for financial worries to stand in the way of that joy.
Becoming a parent is full of surprises – not least of all finding out that, for such small beings, babies cause a lot of chaos and expense.
Here are some ideas for getting that budget in shape, ready for being a one income family.
See what names are trending this year.