Jump to content

Gifted children Parliamentary Enquiry


  • Please log in to reply
93 replies to this topic

#76 TeaTimeTreat

Posted 23 December 2012 - 10:34 AM

QUOTE (somila @ 23/12/2012, 10:21 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
This is a real problem - there are so many reasons a child could be in the "bottom stream" and these classes can be horrible.  I did hear a teacher say she had worked at a school where they assigned two teachers each class in this stream so that one could keep teaching while the other dealt with behavioural issues if necessary.  She said it worked better than having one teacher in a smaller class size.

Expelling children with behavioural issues isn't really a system that "works better" is it?


No not really, it benefits some children and disadvantages others, just like class streaming does, the irony is that children who are well behaved hard workers but who take longer to "get it" and children with learning disabilities actually need a non disruptive classroom even more than the bright children with no issues, because for them it can mean the difference between leaving school with the quals they need to enter an apprentiship or with nothing at all.



#77 TeaTimeTreat

Posted 23 December 2012 - 10:43 AM

QUOTE (BadCat @ 23/12/2012, 10:30 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Perhaps the answer is larger schools where there is scope for streaming and delineation within those streams for kids with behavioural issues.  I'm sure that comes with it's own set of problems though.


I think bigger schools can help badcat  original.gif , our local primary does not stream but it has a G&T support for yr 1+, OC classes (grade 4+), Strings from grade 3, Band from Grade 5, Mathletics, Debating, a very supportive librarian teacher and the kids seem to always be in some sort of academic competition. Of course the irony is that because of this the school attracts lots of bright, gifted and talented children (and to be fair lots of middle class ones as well), this raises the class averages anyway so in effect the whole school is streamed in a way.



#78 BadCat

Posted 23 December 2012 - 10:59 AM

QUOTE
I would have thought that the proportion of gifted children is about 1%,


For those that think of gifted in terms of either Stephen Hawking or average try thinking of it on a scale of 1-10 just like beauty.

Your average looking person is a 5.  Someone a bit ugly might be a 3.  2 is downiright ugly and 1 is ugly enough to stop traffic.  A 7 is attractive, an 8 is better and a 10 is drop dead gorgeous.

Same with intelligence.  A 5 is average.  A 1 is Homer Simpson.  A 10 is Stephen Hawking.  There are lots of 8s in our schools who need better programs.

#79 kadoodle

Posted 23 December 2012 - 01:49 PM

QUOTE (BadCat @ 23/12/2012, 11:59 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
For those that think of gifted in terms of either Stephen Hawking or average try thinking of it on a scale of 1-10 just like beauty.

Your average looking person is a 5.  Someone a bit ugly might be a 3.  2 is downiright ugly and 1 is ugly enough to stop traffic.  A 7 is attractive, an 8 is better and a 10 is drop dead gorgeous.

Same with intelligence.  A 5 is average.  A 1 is Homer Simpson.  A 10 is Stephen Hawking.  There are lots of 8s in our schools who need better programs.



Very well put, Badcat.

We've been very lucky in my kids' current school to have enough support staff to work with the kids in the lower streams as well as enable the higher streamed kids to be extended.  We also have a very active parent body and a lot of volunteer parents to go over the rote learning of the 2 times tables and the alphabet at one end and help with algebra and dissect Robert Frost at the other.

I'm really happy for them, and jealous that my schooling was so much different.

#80 leisamd

Posted 23 December 2012 - 03:13 PM

Quill, your post is so interesting! I have my children in music aswell, to enrich without running too far ahead. Dd is working 1-2 years ahead in academic work, and is midway through suzuki violin book 2, & starting piano this year at her request.  . I do not think she's gifted though, bright, and would likely coast along as average if she wasn't challenged. Ds1 is similar. Maybe they'd be 7's ish... original.gif

#81 Guest_bottle~rocket_*

Posted 23 December 2012 - 05:30 PM

QUOTE (BadCat @ 23/12/2012, 11:59 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
For those that think of gifted in terms of either Stephen Hawking or average try thinking of it on a scale of 1-10 just like beauty.

Your average looking person is a 5.  Someone a bit ugly might be a 3.  2 is downiright ugly and 1 is ugly enough to stop traffic.  A 7 is attractive, an 8 is better and a 10 is drop dead gorgeous.

Same with intelligence.  A 5 is average.  A 1 is Homer Simpson.  A 10 is Stephen Hawking.  There are lots of 8s in our schools who need better programs.


Just because I was questioning the rate of giftedness quoted in the article doesn't mean I think of it in terms of Stephen Hawking or average.  Actually the Stephen Hawkings of this world are probably closer to one in a million than one per cent.

If someone is on the 80th centile for IQ then they would not be gifted by any measure, they would be bright (not that there is anything wrong with that). I would have thought that a teacher in a mainstream class should be able to meet the needs of bright students. It is their job to cater for a range of abilities.  It is the gifted kids that are being failed by the education system.

Edited by bottle~rocket, 24 December 2012 - 08:20 AM.


#82 kadoodle

Posted 23 December 2012 - 06:00 PM

You're thinking linear rather than exponential, bottle-rocket.

#83 Guest_bottle~rocket_*

Posted 23 December 2012 - 06:06 PM

QUOTE (kadoodle @ 23/12/2012, 07:00 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
You're thinking linear rather than exponential, bottle-rocket.


Yes, but Badcat was talking about a scale of 1 to 10 which usually is a linear scale.  It is a pretty simplistic way to describe it.

QUOTE
For those that think of gifted in terms of either Stephen Hawking or average try thinking of it on a scale of 1-10 just like beauty.

Edited by bottle~rocket, 23 December 2012 - 06:07 PM.


#84 leisamd

Posted 23 December 2012 - 06:26 PM

Hi quill, thanks for your post!  I appreciate what you've written and will ponder it! On my phone so please forgive brevity!

my daughter was 7 in july, she just finished her 3rd year of violin lessons, not pure suzuki method but primarily suzuki, her teacher is suzuki qualified.
Dd is relishing the more difficult songs, working on hook stroke at the moment actually. She has an excellent ear which suits suzuki method. I was just speaking with her teacher about ameb exams last week, we plan to start soon but not at the expense of suzuki repertoireo.  We are also working on note reading but I had considered beginning ameb theory, especially with the course now online in the early grades, not sure yet, her workload is fairly full for next year already. I suspect she'd do well, maths is a strength. Dexterity is pretty good, she draws all day long so fine motor is good, but she needs more strength especially for 4th finger. Emotional maturity of a 7 year old!
Interesting about the corresponding physical aspects, I'll have to pull out some elastics!

So much for brevity! Must go, my sons are destroying my bathroom!

#85 BadCat

Posted 23 December 2012 - 06:35 PM

I know the 1 to 10 thing was simplistic but a lot of people seem to think you need to be profoundly gifted or you're not gifted at all.  That was the impression I had from your (I think?) post.  Apologies if I misunderstood.

And yes, a teacher or indeed a school should be able to cater to the bright or mild to moderately gifted students.  But so often they don't.  And if you dare raise the issue people roll their eyes and you can almost hear them thinking "Oh here's another pushy mum with no idea".  It's frustrating trying to get a school to lift it's game to engage your child.  My school finally put some effort into it when my youngest was in year 6.  Too little, too late.

Edited by BadCat, 23 December 2012 - 06:36 PM.


#86 Canberra Chick

Posted 23 December 2012 - 06:43 PM

I don't think DS is anything like gifted, but he is very bright for his age, if a wee bit lazy if something challenges him as he is used to doing well. His school has a differentiated curriculum and they 'stream' within class, so DS is on the top reading table, usually top for maths but occasionally drops to second table. Kids are not fixed in their stream, can move up or down if they don't get that bit of the curriculum (typically maths). DS and a couple of other kids in the class do extension activities too. I feel quite happy with this, especially as his extension time does not eat into other areas of the curriculum, like music, which he loves. Whereas as a kid, I got maths extension work when the other kids were doing pottery, which would have been great for my rather poor fine motor skills!

I did talk to his teacher about home readers, as they had nothing for DS's level, but she was happy for him to read his own things at home, and as he would rather read than do most things, that wasn't hard!

I was concerned last year as his ability seemed to fall away. It turned out he was bored and switched off. This year the school has been more pro active in challenging the brighter kids. His biggest problem is his fine motor skills as his writing can't match his thinking. I'm sure he'd love to dictate all his work!

#87 BlondieUK

Posted 23 December 2012 - 07:02 PM

QUOTE (Bek+3 @ 23/12/2012, 06:17 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
The article really hit the nail on the head when it said that children gifted in sports are celebrated and embraced. There is certainly not the case for the academic children at all. My academically advanced child has 2 left feet and butter fingers when it comes to sport. If he had sporting ability though no doubt he would be taken under someones wing and have that gift nurtured for sure. It just shows what we really value in this country and how it differs from the experience my MIL had with my DH growing up in the UK.


There are mechanisms and support for musically gifted children - but as Quill will know - these are usually only existent outside of the school structure. Private teachers, private classes - and it costs a fortune. The bigger government schools, or the music-oriented schools, have great programs, but they tend to only really kick in at secondary. There is a real dearth of top quality arts programs in Australian primary schools, and I a not sure that the ANC addresses this problem in any substantial way.


QUOTE (Bek+3 @ 23/12/2012, 06:28 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I wonder if, as a 'society', our tall poppy mentality is the reason why we have nothing in place to embrace and advance children further who are academically gifted.


Yes, yes, yes. I have worked as a teacher in Asia, and (while I fundamentally disagree with a national hot-housing system that places an insane amount of pressure on even very young children) education is the #1 priority for most families. Children who show any kinds of giftedness have those gifts nurtured and extended as far as families are able to.

I do wonder if it goes back to our modern roots as a 'poneering' nation - where hard work is about the 'hard yakka' physical work, and the wor of the brain is, in many ways, treated as suspicious or secondary. America (while having its own education issues) has managed to avoid this, and despite a profoundly problematic school system, certainly does - in theory - support gifted learning. They hav some of the best universities in the world.

QUOTE (sparkler @ 23/12/2012, 07:14 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
At my school the children in the top stream were happy and did well, the children in the middle strean has some disruptive behaviour but not all the time so did ok, it was the children in the bottom stream that really suffered though as it was made up of the disruptive children, children who were well behaved but struggled with academic learning and children with disabilities, the children with behavioural issues made it nearly impossible for the children who wanted to learn. I tested around the 75th centile but as I am dyslexic I was put in the bottom stream. Streamed classes in the private system might work better though as they can expel the children with major behavioural issues.

Essentially streaming works for the kids in the top stream but you have to be willing to write off 1/3rd of kids to do it if we are talking about state schools, thankfully my DS is testing as above average (but not gifted) and free of learning disabilities right now so he would probably be ok in a streamed system.


I find this post quite disgusting. Any solution which 'writes off' 1/3 of children is unbelievably stupid an narrow minded. What on earth makes you think that profoundly gifted children cannot also be profoundly disabled? To use my son as an example - he tests with an IQ around 70, and is ASD/DHD and has sensory and behavioural issues (although some of these are resolving a bit). But - he also has perfect pitch, and the musical equivilant of a photographic memory. The child can sing a complete Beethoven symphony from beginning to end from memory, in the right key, and varies the parts (sometimes he sings the 'tune', and sometimes he sings inner string parts that even I struggle to hear). His giftedness in this area deserves support and extension, but getting past the other learning issues is incredibly difficult. Does he deserve extension any less than a child without a disability?

Gifted children, in my experience, often come with other 'issues' - whether they be social, emotional, behavioural, or in tandem with a learning difficulty. It's not as simple as shove all the bright kids in a classroom together and everything will be ok. Just like it's not as simple as shove all the 'bad' kids in a classroom together. It's far more complex than that and simplistic solutions such as streaming are so individual to any one school or context as to be almost useless as a general guideline.

R2 - are you living in Hampshire?


QUOTE (BadCat @ 23/12/2012, 09:30 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
To be honest I don't know how best to deal with those issues in the bottom stream.  I wish I did.

What I do know is that it is utterly wrong to make smart kids twiddle their thumbs while everyone else catches up.  If it was only happening once in a while then it wouldn't be a problem.  But when a child routinely gets everything the first time it is pure torture to sit through several more weeks of lessons showing the same thing in a variety of ways while everyone else gets it.  Even when there is streaming there will be kids who have this problem.  DD frequently comes home from year 8 rolling her eyes in exasperation at the fact that they are STILL doing x when she understood it two weeks ago.

Perhaps the answer is larger schools where there is scope for streaming and delineation within those streams for kids with behavioural issues.  I'm sure that comes with it's own set of problems though.


One of the answers is that teachers should not be teaching in 'class sets' - there needs to be genuine extension work ready to go with any activity/unit. It's something where inquiry based learning has a lot to offer - set children an open ended problem (ie a problem with several/many solutions). It gets them to think laterally, but also to apply the knowledge they have in new and exiting ways.

QUOTE (leisamd @ 23/12/2012, 05:26 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
We are also working on note reading but I had considered beginning ameb theory, especially with the course now online in the early grades, not sure yet, her workload is fairly full for next year already.


I am spending my Xmas holidays writing a new curriculum for Years 6-9 Music for my new job starting Jan 7th. I can't find a link that does AMEB theory online - can someone paste it here, please?


#88 TeaTimeTreat

Posted 23 December 2012 - 07:38 PM

QUOTE (BlondieUK @ 23/12/2012, 07:02 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I find this post quite disgusting. Any solution which 'writes off' 1/3 of children is unbelievably stupid an narrow minded. What on earth makes you think that profoundly gifted children cannot also be profoundly disabled? To use my son as an example - he tests with an IQ around 70, and is ASD/DHD and has sensory and behavioural issues (although some of these are resolving a bit). But - he also has perfect pitch, and the musical equivilant of a photographic memory. The child can sing a complete Beethoven symphony from beginning to end from memory, in the right key, and varies the parts (sometimes he sings the 'tune', and sometimes he sings inner string parts that even I struggle to hear). His giftedness in this area deserves support and extension, but getting past the other learning issues is incredibly difficult. Does he deserve extension any less than a child without a disability?

Gifted children, in my experience, often come with other 'issues' - whether they be social, emotional, behavioural, or in tandem with a learning difficulty. It's not as simple as shove all the bright kids in a classroom together and everything will be ok. Just like it's not as simple as shove all the 'bad' kids in a classroom together. It's far more complex than that and simplistic solutions such as streaming are so individual to any one school or context as to be almost useless as a general guideline.


Did you miss the part where I mentioned that I was in the bottom stream? Or the part where I mentioned that I tested as bright but as I had a learning disability I was put in the bottom stream for everything? It was my experience that yes the kids in the bottom stream where written off by the teachers and the education system, it was a case of 80% behaviour management and 20% learning. I am well aware that children can be twice exceptional and since I have a child who has gone from GDD to above average I also know what kids can do with the right support, which is why we need a system that supports all children.

I might have a learning disability but at least I don't go around declaring people's posts are disgusting for no good reason!



#89 BlondieUK

Posted 23 December 2012 - 07:42 PM

Sorry - bad wording - the concept in the post. And collective 'you'.

Streaming can work - but it takes quality teaching, and you don't have to write of 1/3rd of children to do it.

Edited by BlondieUK, 23 December 2012 - 07:43 PM.


#90 leisamd

Posted 23 December 2012 - 07:44 PM

BlondieUK, try this link http://www.amebtheory.edu.au

original.gif

Edited by leisamd, 23 December 2012 - 07:45 PM.


#91 kadoodle

Posted 23 December 2012 - 07:48 PM

QUOTE (Canberra chick @ 23/12/2012, 07:43 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
His biggest problem is his fine motor skills as his writing can't match his thinking. I'm sure he'd love to dictate all his work!


Teach him to type.  In trying to keep up with my brain, my handwriting looked like a spider had climbed out of the inkwell and had an epileptic fit on the page.  90wpm on Mum's clunky old typewriter felt like magic.

Sparkler - I think Blondie was inferring that writing children off was disgusting, not that your post or you were.  FWIW, I think that giving up on children is disgusting, abhorrant and just sodding lazy.  But when you spend 80% of your classtime dealing with behavioural stuff, I imagine it would be easy to lose focus.  A great many of my teachers in high school were just childminders trying to stop riots rather than educators engaging us in learning.

#92 BlondieUK

Posted 23 December 2012 - 07:53 PM

That is what I meant, sorry, sparkle. Supervising children watching Tree Fu Tom and jumping around the living room as I type.

#93 TeaTimeTreat

Posted 23 December 2012 - 07:55 PM

QUOTE (BlondieUK @ 23/12/2012, 07:42 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Sorry - bad wording - the concept in the post. And collective 'you'.

Streaming can work - but it takes quality teaching, and you don't have to write of 1/3rd of children to do it.


That's cool,

I think the worst thing was that those of us in the bottom stream were only allowed to sit a maths GSCE exam that allowed us to get a D at most, so even if you had the ability to pass you couldn't because you were a bottom stream kid and therefore not eligible.

I got a D, can you tell I am still p*ssed lol.

Sorry for the derail OP.



#94 =R2=

Posted 24 December 2012 - 09:50 AM

QUOTE (Quill @ 23/12/2012, 11:47 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I’d love to hear her, if you have any clips. No pressure – I’m not interested in critique – just is always interesting to hear young musicians developing. All the very best – Howdo is another with musical children.

Sending you a YouTube clip as we speak. Her strength is piano though. Would love your critique actually. Thanks!

QUOTE (BlondieUK @ 23/12/2012, 07:02 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
R2 - are you living in Hampshire?

DH is Hampshire born and bred but we live in Australia original.gif. We were there for Christmas last year.




2 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 2 guests, 0 anonymous users

 

Ada Nicodemou: 'I can never be completely happy again'

Home and Away actress Ada Nicodemou has opened up about the loss of her stillborn baby.

10 things to consider when you're thinking about trying for a baby

Before you start tracking your menstrual cycle and reading up on the best positions to get pregnant, there are a few other things you may want to consider.

Baby Gammy's dad tries to claim charity money

The biological father of baby Gammy has reportedly tried to access charity money raised for the little boy's medical costs.

How special surgery and IVF can create a post-vasectomy baby

Cricket legend Glenn McGrath and his second wife Sara are expecting their first child together, thanks to IVF and a delicate surgical sperm retrieval process that helped the couple to conceive.

Belle Gibson's mother 'disgusted and embarrassed'

The mother of disgraced wellness blogger Belle Gibson has accused her daughter of lying about her childhood in an attempt to garner public sympathy.

Life On Mars

It's men who need 'retraining', not women

We are all responsible for our own behaviour. Telling victims to harden up is wrong.

Doctor's mobile phone 'left inside c-section mum'

A new mum claims a doctor left his mobile phone inside her after delivering her baby via caesarean section.

I'm a mum and I'm following my dreams

I want my kids to know that no matter what happens in life, you can still be who it is that you've always wanted to be.

Those first daycare days

I had this innate 'mum' moment the other day.

'If one person had listened, my life would have been so different'

Katherine's father will die in prison for the horrifying sexual abuse of his daughter. Yet she is the one with the true life sentence.

Couple to celebrate terminally ill baby's birthday in unique way

Baby Jai Bishop has lived at Starship Hospital for the past seven months, with his parents flying back and forth from Hokitika, 1100km away, to be by his side.

This new plan undermines breastfeeding and baby health at everyone's expense

Mothers, babies, the health system and the wider society are going to pay the price of this new budget.

Trying to understand why your baby is upset

Working out what?s underlying your baby's fussiness can be a case of trial and error. Here are a few common causes and how you can remedy each one.

When those you love judge your parenting

In today's society, never has it been harder to parent without judgment. But what about when judgment is coming from closer to home?

Don't play the victim blame game with family violence

It's not a woman's job to teach violent men how to behave.

11 truths about having two under two

When I told my mothers? group that my husband and I had started trying for our second baby they told me I was crazy. Now I can see why.

'How do you say goodbye to someone you've only just started to get to know?'

New mum Sarah Sutton was faced with a shattering scenario no person should have to endure.

It's a ... boy! Couple welcomes son number 13

"It's a boy!" That's the phrase Kateri Schwandt has heard in labour delivery ward for the 13th time in her life.

Six reasons to go for a walk

Can't find time to get to the gym? It could be just as beneficial to put your baby in the stroller and go for a walk.

Seven questions you should be asking about your health cover

If the last time you assessed your health cover was five years ago, there?s a chance it may no longer suit your needs. To ensure it?s still right for your family, click here for seven questions to ask.

 
Advertisement
 
Advertisement
 
 
 

What's hot on EB

Where are the childcare places?

It?s all very well to encourage women to work if they choose to, but how can the measures lead to increased workforce participation when women are once again left holding the baby?

The pain of not having babies and not knowing why

After seven years of wishing, hoping, crying, punching pillows and shouting "why me?!", the end result is more than I ever thought possible.

Getting your family finances in order

Whether you're after a new car for a growing family, a bigger house, or are just fixing up your finances, here are the basics on borrowing.

Mum shares graphic selfie to warn against tanning

A mum has shared a graphic photo of her skin cancer treatment as a warning to others.

Does parenthood make us happier?

We can certainly gain higher levels of happiness when we become parents, but the trick is to not get overwhelmed by the pressures of raising our kids.

No, having a dog is not like having a human child

It's obvious these people dote on their pets, but they're barking up the wrong tree.

Toddler styling

Seven things my toddler taught me about my home

My standards at home were never that high but having a two-year-old has taught me to be cool with chaos.

Australia's top baby names of 2014

The numbers have been crunched and it's official: Australian parents are having a bit of an 'O' moment.

How to set up the perfect nursery for your baby

You'll soon be meeting your baby, but you've got one big task to get done first: setting up a comfy, calming nursery you'll both be able to enjoy.

Childcare rebate: tougher rules for stay-at-home mums

A new form of activity testing will be introduced to ensure the highest subsidies go to parents who contribute the most to the workforce.

The women who desperately need more support in pregnancy

For women suffering from chronic morning sickness or hyperemesis gravidarum, pregnancy can be the roller coaster from hell.

When labour doesn't happen and you're induced

I never actually went into labour - so by 42 weeks I was booked in for induction.

Mum's grief for triplets inspires change

The death of Sophie Smith's triplet baby boys has motivated the half-marathon mother and her team to raise $1.25 million for charity.

The best advice for treating head lice

Just like a horror movie ... THEY'RE BAAAAAACK. So what works in treating and avoiding head lice and nits?

Overdue and over it

A watched womb never labours ... or at least mine didn't.

Parenting an early walker

Watching your child take their first wobbly steps is one of the best parenting highs you'll ever experience. But with that high comes a new reality.

Baby-led weaning worked for us

My baby wasn't interested in food - until we tried something new. Now she's eating it all, and it often comes from my plate.

'Paralysed bride' becomes a mum

Rachelle Friedman Chapman was preparing to marry the man of her dreams when tragedy struck four years ago.

 

Top baby names

Baby Names

The numbers are in and we can now bring you the 2014 top baby name list for Australia.

 
Advertisement
 
 
Essential Baby and Essential Kids is the place to find parenting information and parenting support relating to conception, pregnancy, birth, babies, toddlers, kids, maternity, family budgeting, family travel, nutrition and wellbeing, family entertainment, kids entertainment, tips for the family home, child-friendly recipes and parenting. Try our pregnancy due date calculator to determine your due date, or our ovulation calculator to predict ovulation and your fertile period. Our pregnancy week by week guide shows your baby's stages of development. Access our very active mum's discussion groups in the Essential Baby forums or the Essential Kids forums to talk to mums about conception, pregnancy, birth, babies, toddlers, kids and parenting lifestyle. Essential Baby also offers a baby names database of more than 22,000 baby names, popular baby names, boys' names, girls' names and baby names advice in our baby names forum. Essential Kids features a range of free printable worksheets for kids from preschool years through to primary school years. For the latest baby clothes, maternity clothes, maternity accessories, toddler products, kids toys and kids clothing, breastfeeding and other parenting resources, check out Essential Baby and Essential Kids.