Jump to content

Internet copyright/content question

  • Please log in to reply
3 replies to this topic

#1 katpaws

Posted 07 December 2012 - 07:14 AM

I am aware of a website that provides a forum for people to put up reviews of goods and services provided by various companies. I was reading the reviews about a specific company and found that the text in some of the reviews was very familiar. When i checked the company's website i found that a few of the recommendations from clients on their webpage had been directly transferred to the review website (that is, word for word) by people who had set up new accounts (newbies) and had never undertaken any other reviews or comments for that consumer website again. Other recommendations on the company's website have been directly taken from a client questionnaire and were not in fact recommendations written by clients (these are not on the consumer website).

I contacted the consumer (review) website about the fact that it would appear that a few of the reviews on the website were not genuine and that there may be breaches of copyright, but many days later I have not heard from the moderators of that website. I was told if i disagreed with the reviews I could add a comment, however, none of my comments have been allowed so far by the moderators of the website (and they were not inflammatory, it was just this comment is what has been posted on the company's website so please make sure you talk about this company with people who you know that have actually used their goods/services).

Or have i got it wrong? It is perfectly legal and/or ethical for client recommendations to appear on consumer review sites? Is it also legal and/or ethical for a business to put up as client recommendations that are from a questionnaire and where it maybe possible that the clients do not know their details and comments have been put on the web?

#2 Sassy Dingo

Posted 07 December 2012 - 09:15 AM

QUOTE (katpaws @ 07/12/2012, 07:14 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Or have i got it wrong? It is perfectly legal and/or ethical for client recommendations to appear on consumer review sites? Is it also legal and/or ethical for a business to put up as client recommendations that are from a questionnaire and where it maybe possible that the clients do not know their details and comments have been put on the web?

Could it be that the customer submitted a comment to both the business and the review website? If it is the business who submitted the comments it is unethical but not illegal. What law do you suggest they are breaking? They may be contravening the terms and conditions of the review website, but then it would be up to the review website to enforce.

Are you also sure that the business is putting up the correct client details? Seems silly to me. If I was going to put a fake review up, I would make up the details so that no one could confirm it was incorrect. If they are their clients details and they did not consent to having them put on the website I would contact the website with proof of identify and also the business and they should take them down. However if they refuse I don't know what you can practically do about it. I am not aware of any law that they are breaking (I would have to review the application of the privacy act, but from memory it only applies to very large companies).

#3 solongsuckers

Posted 07 December 2012 - 09:30 AM

Maybe the business has copied it form the review website?

I'm not sure why it matters that the same comments appear in both places.

#4 katpaws

Posted 07 December 2012 - 10:02 AM

My concern it that there are all these positive reivews of this company on the consumer website that have been put up by people who have set up an account soley for the purpose of transferring "their" recommendation letter from the business website to the consumer website, that is, they are not genuine reviews but are probably in fact the business creating member accounts to promote their business online (without paying for advertising). While i could go maybe one or two posts saying this business is wonderful and quoting word for word their recommendation that they have given to the business, the number of new accounts doing the same thing is large enough to question how genuine these reviews are.

The guidelines for the consumer website include that the reviews must be a genuine review of a user of that service or good; and from what i can see they are not. I also have an issue with questionnaire responses being put up as recommendations as i am concerned that people have not given their consent for their personal details (ie name, where they live) on the business's website and may not be aware of this.

The company in question is not a good one and they are known for very unethical and illegal practices. I worry that more people will get trapped in their web and will be taken in by reviews that are most probably the business copying and pasting "recommendations" from their website to other websites.

My understanding is that with copyright you cannot transfer exact content (ie words) from one website to another without referencing the original source. I have no problem with people saying "This is what i told the company: blah blah and quoting their recommendation. I have a problem with a company doing a cut and paste job pretending to be the clients to drum up more business (and suckers).

Maybe the business has copied it form the review website?

No, the reviews are copied word for word from "recommendations" from the business website; that is the original source.

Edited by katpaws, 07 December 2012 - 10:07 AM.

1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users


Kourtney Kardashian goes nude for art

We've all done some pretty radical things after a big break-up, but Kourtney Kardashian has gone one better.

Video shows babies 'singing' to music in the womb

A new study has shown that babies may actually be able to hear from as early as 16 weeks – 10 weeks earlier than was commonly thought.

Prevent pelvic pain with pre-pregnancy exercise: study

Women who want to stave off aches and pains in pregnancy should exercise regularly before they conceive, experts say.

Dad's hilarious blog about life with twins

A stand-up comedian in the UK has plenty of new material since becoming a dad to twin boys.

Dinosaur products for babies and toddlers

Dinosaurs are one of those classic childhood crazes. We've put together a host of products for dinosaur-mad parents, babies and toddlers.

Restaurant manager sticks up for noisy baby

A mum was left upset by a note from neighbouring diners saying her screaming baby had ruined their dinner.

His name is Cayden: Mum and social media hit back after racist Facebook attack

When a man posted a selfie with a co-worker's son to Facebook, it became a magnet for racist comments.

The Chinese tradition for new mums that can now cost $37,000 a month

Opulent rest time is becoming the gold standard in postpartum recovery, inspired by a Chinese confinement custom known as "sitting the month".

How the media can shape our decisions when it comes to labour

We all like to think that we make our choices in fair, reasoned and well-thought out ways. Not many of us would admit that we allowed the media to influence us in our life choices.

Mum told to express in pet relief area at airport

A woman who flew from Boston to Washington says staff with United Airlines at Washington's Dulles Airport suggested she pump her breast milk in the pet-relief area.

Heartbreak as mum dies and her baby chokes to death

An Australian woman living in the US collapsed and died while feeding her baby, who then choked to death on his food. 

The hidden mental health illness of anxiety

Anxiety took over Robyn Read's life to such an extent she could not even buy the groceries and felt suicidal.

Two children fall from second storey window

Two young boys have been rushed to hospital after falling out a second-storey window of a home in Eastwood.

Mum gives birth to India's heaviest baby

An Indian woman has given birth to a baby boy weighing a whopping 5.97kg, setting a new record for the country's heaviest baby.

Grandma surprised with brand new granddaughter

Finding out you’re going to be a grandmother can be a very emotional moment. Finding out that you’re a grandmother and the baby is already here is just out of this world.

Saltwater Sandals for babies and toddlers

Many mamas are wearing Saltwater Sandals - why not buy them for your babies and toddlers too?

How to spring clean your body and mind

Whether you're pregnant, already a mum, or are just trying to be a bit more healthy, there are ways to use the rejuvenating season to give yourself a boost.


What's hot on EB

Stella McCartney honours mum with lacy bra

Fashion designer Stella McCartney has honoured her late mum, Linda McCartney, by designing a special bra for post-mastectomy patients.

Don't panic: A granddad midwife's guide for dads-to-be

Mark Harris has helped deliver 500 babies. And he's now telling fathers what to expect.

How to be a calm parent when you're feeling anything but

Being a calm parent takes a lot of work, sometimes more than is obvious to those around us.

The joy and isolation of being a stay-at-home dad

It's cool, kind of like a second childhood. I love him to bits and think, on average, I'm an okay dad. But I also want to talk about the other stuff.

How baby Teddy's short life is helping save thousands of lives

He may have only lived for 100 minutes, but that didn't stop baby Teddy from saving the lives of others.

A heartbreaking trail of missed chances in death of baby forgotten in car

A haunting reminder to stay mindful about babies in cars, especially as we approach summer.

What to do if your baby has tongue-tie

Tongue-tie can cause feeding problems. However once it is diagnosed, the condition can be easily treated.

How to move house without losing your mind

Some people move frequently, while others like to stay put. But everyone finds it stressful.

'She had nowhere to go': how new mum's life began to unravel

The birth of her first child should have been happiest of times for Campsie mother Phuong Cao, but friends say it marked the beginning of when her life began to unravel. 

Women giving birth to a son keep some of his Y chromosomes

It was an experiment doomed to failure - they were looking for male cells in female bodies. And their search was stunningly successful.

Photos: How babies fit in the womb

A gorgeous photo series shows babies in the first hours after their birth - as they were positioned in the womb.

Baby tries to persuade stubborn bulldog to walk, fails

We don't know what he's saying, but this baby has a very clear message for his bulldog pal: let's walk - NOW.

The best toddler gift ever? Nine gender-neutral play kitchen picks

Without a doubt, one of the best gifts for a toddler turning two or three is a play kitchen.

9 easy steps to improve your baby photography

With a few simple tips you can take your images from random happy snaps to lovely clean images that create beautiful lasting memories.



Can't decide?

Check out the Essential Baby Names section for some inspiration

Essential Baby and Essential Kids is the place to find parenting information and parenting support relating to conception, pregnancy, birth, babies, toddlers, kids, maternity, family budgeting, family travel, nutrition and wellbeing, family entertainment, kids entertainment, tips for the family home, child-friendly recipes and parenting. Try our pregnancy due date calculator to determine your due date, or our ovulation calculator to predict ovulation and your fertile period. Our pregnancy week by week guide shows your baby's stages of development. Access our very active mum's discussion groups in the Essential Baby forums or the Essential Kids forums to talk to mums about conception, pregnancy, birth, babies, toddlers, kids and parenting lifestyle. Essential Baby also offers a baby names database of more than 22,000 baby names, popular baby names, boys' names, girls' names and baby names advice in our baby names forum. Essential Kids features a range of free printable worksheets for kids from preschool years through to primary school years. For the latest baby clothes, maternity clothes, maternity accessories, toddler products, kids toys and kids clothing, breastfeeding and other parenting resources, check out Essential Baby and Essential Kids.