Jump to content
11 replies to this topic
Posted 31 October 2012 - 07:28 AM
Hi folks, wondering if anybody has any experience with this.
We have very old batts in our roof. We have had a few quotes to get new roofing insulation. A couple said they would just lay new batts on top of the old, which would be about 1K. But one said that you cant do that because there will be gaps which stop it working, so you need to have the old batts taken out at an additional cost of about 1K.
Has anybody had either of these options done, and what difference did it make to your house?
Thanks very much!
Posted 31 October 2012 - 01:40 PM
We had a similar thing, one company said they'd lay batts on top, and that removing the old ones would be really expensive.
Then another guy came and said look, the amount of asbestos it would stir up (there is asbestos in our roof, and old batts are sometimes asbestos too), I wouldn't bother, you have old batts there and the added energy saving from replacing them with new batts wouldn't be significant, and you shouldn't just lay the new ones on top.
He seemed very un dodgy and of course wasn't trying to sell us anything, so we believed him!
Posted 31 October 2012 - 06:23 PM
Thanks CallMeAliG. Did you go ahead with the insulation? Im interested to hear what sort of difference it makes (bearing in mind that theres other factors like windows and orientation of the house coming into it)
Posted 31 October 2012 - 06:36 PM
We got new roof insulation put in a few years ago when they were doing a grants for installing it.We had really old roof insulation and were told it would be better to get it removed, which we did they came with a big truck and massive vacuum and suck it all out.Then got new batts layed, we have noticed a reasonable difference particularly in winter keeping the heat in.
Posted 01 November 2012 - 12:09 PM
We had the horrible old insulation stuff. It was thinner than the width of your little finger - so not doing anything insulation wise.
While getting quotes - the removal seemed the biggest cost - its labour intensive. Hubby got in the roof and got rid of it, we put it into large black bin bags and he and dad took it up the tip. You have to check with them and dump it in the right section though - it may have cost extra, but nowhere near the Company doing it.
If you do this get hubby to wear old clothing and old shoes /joggers/socks that can be chucked out straight away ( and he did get itchy and sweaty from being in the roof).We are in WA so no surprise there!!
I think we had 3.5 rating batts installed - the golden ones and they've been terriffic. People really notice how cool the house is / warm in winter.
Posted 01 November 2012 - 03:12 PM
Just asked my builder and he said you have to take out the old ones so the new ones will work properly.
Posted 01 November 2012 - 03:20 PM
Hubby got in the roof and got rid of it, we put it into large black bin bags and he and dad took it up the tip.
Be very, very careful about this - see PPs post re. asbestos in older buildings. I'm assuming because you got quotes done prior to removal it would have been pointed out if there was any asbestos in the roof?
Posted 12 November 2012 - 12:11 PM
Pretty sure we dont have any asbestos in the roof, but hubbys not keen to remove them himself as he gets asthma, and Im 8 months pregnant with back pain and sciatica so I dont think either of us will be doing it!
Far out I still dont know what to think...
Good to hear from those who say the batts improved their comfort, thanks for that
Posted 14 November 2012 - 08:34 PM
No - no mention of asbestos in the roof.
My god - the special removal and precautions for that would have blown the quote out astronomically!!!
Posted 14 November 2012 - 08:44 PM
I work for an insulation company in SA. You need to have the old insulation removed so that the new stuff will work effectively.
Often the older insulation is made up of product completely useless in actually insulating... You would be surprised what we have come across.
Posted 14 November 2012 - 08:47 PM
Also, depending on the size of your house and what sort of roof you have and how many down lights etc $1000 for install is pretty cheap. That's assuming they're doing a legit job and you will still be able to see the joists etc.
Posted 14 November 2012 - 08:50 PM
How old is old? My parents have just last week gotten a quote for new insulation for their town house(around 30 years old, maybe a few years less) and were quoted 1k. Mum never mentioned removal of the old stuff, but she said in the ACT 5 batts are recommended, not the 2.5 they had.
Can they just stick new ones on top if they aren't TOO old?
1 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users
Everyone loves a personalised Christmas present - especially those which have been lovingly created by little hands. These Christmas gifts are so easy that even your toddler will be able to make them.
Our friends at The Sun-Herald are giving you the chance to win a family pass to Taronga Zoo Sydney or Taronga Western Plains Zoo.
I?m not ready for my son to stop believing in Santa yet. But should I treat him like the intelligent and sensible boy that he is and tell the truth, or should I lie, with the good intentions of keeping the magic alive for just a little longer?
More than half a million lights, countless hours of work, a world record - and it's all for a good cause.
Doctors made a shocking discovery when they found a dandelion growing inside 16-month-old?s ear canal.
Introducing the new campaign to help mums and babies around Australia.
Despite safety campaigns by organisations such as Kidsafe, the number of children dying and being injured in driveway accidents has remained steady. One mother shares her story of loss and warns others to pay attention.
Got bored kids? Quickly find the best activities for kids wherever you are in Australia with the Essential Kids app.
Fitness blogger and football wife Caroline Berg Eriksen has come under fire for posting a photo of her amazing post-baby body on Instrgram just four days after giving birth. She has defended the picture saying she is "proud" of what her body has achieved.
A pregnant woman had her baby taken by British social workers after a forced caesarean section - and the child has still not been returned to her.
When kids want something, they'll ask ... and ask ... and ask ... until you cave in. You can teach them to unlearn this annoying tactic by saying just three words.
Babies love getting their little gums around keys - but these ones are cleaner and more fun than the set on your key ring.
Top 5 Articles
Win one of 9 LEGO® DUPLO® Planes? ?Skippers? Flight School set for Christmas. Enter here for your chance to win.
Join Essential Baby and Aldi in celebrating Chrismas, with gift guides, the truth about Santa and how to manage christmas while pregnant + lots more.
Breaking Bad, The Great Gatsby and Game of Thrones are all inspiring baby names in the UK this year ? but royal names are on the decline.
To celebrate the launch of this gorgeous new baby skincare range, Essential Baby is giving our readers the chance to win one of ten Little Bairn Essentials Gift Packs.
For a limited time you can save 50% off when you gift unlimited access to The Age or SMH. It's the gift for those you love, who love to know.
Weird poses, surprise photobombs, bizarre editing: these are the wedding photos that should have never seen the light of day.
Here's a selection of vintage boys and girls monikers which have traditionally been used as either nicknames or given names, from the 1880s through to the 1950s.
Free Printable Activities
Free printable acitivity pages like colouring in, cutting, word finders, mazes, maths activities and puzzles.