State challenges sex offender's IVF plans

IVF
Date
"If he was to reoffend against another child, that would also impact on ABY's biological child" ... Kerri Judd SC.

"If he was to reoffend against another child, that would also impact on ABY's biological child" ... Kerri Judd SC.

A landmark ruling allowing a convicted sex offender's wife to undergo IVF treatment is being challenged by Victoria's patient review panel, which says the decision doesn't put child welfare first.

The law takes care of children who are born ... not to be flippant, but what is in the best interests of an unborn child is to be born 

The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) overturned an automatic ban on IVF access for the 34-year-old man and his wife, but the patient review panel is now urging the Court of Appeal to quash the VCAT ruling.

Convicted child-sex offenders are automatically barred from IVF.

The man, identified as ABY for legal reasons, was convicted in 2009 of having sex with a 16-year-old girl under his care when he was a teacher's aide.

He was jailed for three years, with two years suspended.

The review panel, an independent body formed under health department guidelines, rejected the couple's application to access IVF in November 2010 under the new Assisted Reproductive Treatment Act.

VCAT overturned the ban in July 2011, finding that ABY's risk of reoffending was low, there was no evidence to suggest he would sexually offend against his own child, and his wife should therefore be allowed to receive IVF treatment.

The review panel argued today that VCAT had not considered the indirect harm ABY might pose to a child he fathered through IVF.

"They've only focused on (ABY's) risk of re-offending per se ... if for example he was to reoffend against another child, that would also impact on ABY's biological child," Kerri Judd SC, for the review panel, told the court.

Barrister John Ribbands, for ABY, argued that even if an IVF child's criminally convicted parent did reoffend, it would be extremely rare for a given offence to make that child's very birth an unacceptable risk.

"The law takes care of children who are born ... not to be flippant, but what is in the best interests of an unborn child is to be born," he said.

Speaking to ABC's 7.30 in June 2011, ABY said he was sorry for he'd done, but that it was unfair for his "pure stupidity" to stop him having children.

"Every person deserves the right to have a family. People make mistakes. It's just very trying," he said.

His wife said, "Any person who can conceive a child naturally can and does. There are people with sexual offense and murder charges that have children - and more than one child. Why do they have children and we can’t?"

Chief Justice Marilyn Warren, Justice Pamela Tate and Justice David Beach reserved their decision.

AAP

Related Coverage

Mother and baby.

Should people be able to use the sperm or eggs of their dead partner?

Four experts consider the arguments on forming a family in a harrowing situation.

Fingers crossed

The IVF lottery of joy and sorrow

16 Jun Wendy Squires has a deeply felt opinion that children aren't a given in life - they're a gift. And sadly, it's simply not every woman's lot or luck in life to reproduce.

Landon Hayley

'Strangers paid for our IVF and gave us a baby'

24 Apr Online crowdsourcing is being used to raise funds for all sorts of projects, including a very personal one - to collect enough money to create a baby via IVF.

Why was I made, Mummy?

'Why was I made, Mummy?'

20 Oct For me, my experience on IVF was so inspiring I wrote a book about it, chronicling my story and those of others many of whom I found on the Essential Baby forum.

Prue

'I never thought there would be leftovers'

When Prue Corlette started IVF four years ago, her focus was on conceiving rather than making a decision about leftover embryos.

Generic mum, baby, mother, motherhood, parenting pic.

IVF mum admits: I was wrong to have a baby at 57

8 Nov A woman who became one of Britain’s oldest mothers after IVF treatment has called for an age limit to be placed on the procedure.

Natalie Hayden

Flying solo: more single women choosing IVF

12 Nov Single women in their late 30s are increasingly giving up waiting for "Mr Right", instead turning to IVF to have a baby alone.

child care

Summit to discuss childcare shortages

6 Dec The Minister for Early Childhood and Childcare, Kate Ellis, will tomorrow bring together state and territory ministers to push for the creation of more childcare places around the nation.